Skip to content

Fake Messages From a Pastor or Leader Asking for Gift Cards

Got a text or email from your pastor, priest, or club president asking for gift cards? Learn how to spot this scam and what to do next.

Text and Email ScamsNovember 10, 20265 min read

If you get an email or text message that looks like it came from your pastor, priest, rabbi, or club president asking you to buy gift cards, stop. Do not reply, and do not buy the cards. It is a scam.

A real community leader will never email or text you out of the blue to ask you to buy gift cards for them. Scammers use the names of leaders you trust because they know you are a helpful person.

What it looks like

This scam often starts with a short, friendly message. It may say the leader is busy in a meeting or dealing with a quiet emergency, and ask if you have a minute to do a favor.

When you write back, the sender asks you to buy gift cards from a store like Target, Amazon, Macy’s, or Dollar General. They often say the cards are for a sick church member, a family in need, or a surprise for the staff.

Here is a real email that a scammer sent to church members while pretending to be their pastor:

Suspicious message

From: Unknown sender

to me

Today at 9:41 AM
I'm in a meeting. I can't get away. I'd like you to buy these gift cards from Dollar General. And then, I'll reimburse you.

Red flags in this message

Sometimes the scammer skips the opening question and asks for the gift cards right away, like in this email sent under a parish priest’s name:

Suspicious message

From: Unknown sender

to me

Today at 9:41 AM
I need seven Sephora or Target gift cards, $200 value on each. You should get them at the store. God bless you.

Red flags in this message

After you buy the cards, the scammer asks you to scratch off the silver strip on the back of each card and send the code numbers, or email a photo of the back of the card. A redemption code is the secret number on the back of a gift card that lets someone spend the money on it. Once the scammer has that code, they can spend the money right away, even without holding the plastic card.

How scammers pretend to be your leader
  1. They look up public names

    Scammers visit church websites, newsletters, and club rosters to find the real names of pastors, board members, and officers.

  2. They make a look-alike account

    They create a free email address that shows your leader's real name, or they text from a new phone number and sign the leader's name.

  3. They invent a reason they cannot talk

    They say they are stuck in a prayer meeting, visiting a hospital, or planning a secret surprise so you will not call them to check.

  4. They ask for the card numbers

    They tell you to scratch the back of the gift cards and send a photo of the numbers so they can spend the money right away.

Red flags

Look for these warning signs:

  • They ask for gift cards. Gift cards are for gifts, not for last-minute favors or emergencies. In the first six months of 2026 alone, people reported losing $154.1 million to gift card scams1.

  • They say they cannot talk on the phone. Scammers say they are in a meeting or at the hospital so you will not hear a stranger’s voice if you try to call.

  • They ask you to keep it a secret. They may claim the cards are a surprise gift for the staff or discreet help for a sick member. Just like in a fake grandson bail call, the real goal of secrecy is to keep you from talking to anyone who would spot the trick.

  • The email address or phone number does not match. The display name at the top of the email may show your pastor’s real name. Tap or click that name to see the actual email address. You will see a random address that does not belong to your church or club.

  • It comes from a friend who says their account is broken. Sometimes a scammer breaks into a friend’s real email account and sends a message saying they cannot log in to Amazon and need you to buy a card for them.

What to do

If you got a message like this, follow these steps in order.

  1. Do not reply to the message. Just as you should not reply to a wrong number text, do not write back to ask if it is real. Replying tells the scammer that your phone number or email address is active.

  2. Call the person using a number you already have. Look up your church office, club directory, or address book, and call that number. Never call a phone number given inside the suspicious message.

  3. Let your church or club know. Tell the church office or club president that someone is using their name. They can warn the rest of the group so nobody else loses money.

  4. Delete the message. Once you have warned your group, delete the email or text and block the sender.

If you already bought the gift cards

If you already sent the card numbers or photos of the cards, take these steps right away:

  1. Call the gift card company immediately. Look on the back of the gift card for the customer service phone number. Tell them the card was used in a scam, and ask if any money is still on the card and if they can freeze it or refund you. Please do not blame yourself.

  2. Keep the physical gift cards and your store receipt. You will need the receipt and the numbers on the card when you talk to the gift card company.

  3. Report the scam to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). The FTC is the government agency that tracks consumer fraud. You can report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov or by calling 1‑877‑382‑4357.

Common questions

Did someone hack my pastor’s phone or email?

Usually, no. In most cases, the scammer did not break into your pastor’s real phone or email account. Instead, the scammer made a brand-new email address or used a different phone number, and put your pastor’s name on it so it looks real at first glance.

Why did the message know both my name and my pastor’s name?

Many churches and civic clubs post newsletters, bulletins, or staff lists on their public websites. Scammers read those pages to learn who leads the group and who belongs to it. Sometimes they also trick one person into sharing the member directory.

Is it ever safe to send a photo of the back of a gift card?

No. Sending a photo of the numbers on the back of a gift card is the same as handing someone cash. Anyone who sees those numbers can spend the money on the card right away.

For more information

  1. Gift card scams on the rise as crooks text: 'Can you do me a favor?'freep.com

Keep reading

More in Text and Email Scams

Should You Reply to a Wrong Number Text?

Do not reply to a wrong number text from a stranger. Learn why scammers send these messages, whether replying is dangerous, and how to block them.

How the scam worksText and Email Scams