Skip to content

How an 83-Year‑Old California Man Lost $20,000 to a Fake Tech Support Refund

An 83-year‑old Orange County man handed over $20,000 in cash after a caller claimed to accidentally overpay a $900 computer protection refund.

Real StoriesNovember 10, 20264 min read

In April 2023, an 83-year‑old man in Orange County, California, bought a cyber protection package for his computer1. According to a report by ABC7 Los Angeles, he paid $900 to a company called InstaFix US LLC for the service. His daughter later spoke to ABC7 about what happened, and asked that the station not publish the family’s name.

What happened

In October 2023, about six months after the purchase, the man received a phone call. The caller claimed to work for InstaFix US and said the company was going out of business. Because it was closing, the caller said, the man was getting his full $900 back.

His daughter told ABC7 that the man gave the caller access to his computer through a code, as well as access to his Bank of America accounts.

Clifford Neuman, director of the University of Southern California Center for Computer Systems Security, told ABC7 that criminals often get into a computer using a tool called remote desktop. Remote desktop is software that lets another person see what is on your computer screen and make changes to your system from far away. It usually requires you to type something on your computer to turn on that access.

Once inside the accounts, the caller started with a test transfer of $200. Next, the caller claimed to have accidentally transferred $20,000. According to the man’s daughter, the caller spoke in a panic on the phone.

What the caller says

Oh my gosh! Oh my gosh! Oh I gave you too much money! I'm gonna get fired.

Incoming call

Unknown caller

mobile

Red flags on this call

  • Caller claimed an accidental overpayment after a refund call

  • Caller used panic and a threat of losing a job to pressure the victim

  • Caller had remote access to the victim's computer and bank accounts

  • Money was requested in cash, collected in person

The man agreed to return the money. No outside money had entered his account. His daughter told ABC7 that the caller had moved money from the man’s checking account into his own savings account. The man did not see that the $20,000 came from his own bank.

The caller convinced the man to go to two separate bank branches to withdraw the cash in two smaller amounts, walking him through the process over the phone.

Within minutes, a man showed up at the family’s door to pick up the cash. Skeptical of the situation, the 83-year‑old’s wife tried to stop her husband and took photos on her cell phone. His daughter told ABC7 that he did not listen and handed over the money.

What happened afterward

The Orange County Sheriff’s Department opened a criminal investigation into the case, and Bank of America told the station it was reviewing the matter.

When ABC7 reached out to InstaFix US, the company replied by email that it is a legitimate business. The company stated that it only charges customers by credit card or check made out to the company name, never asks customers to send money any other way, and had no information about the fraud.

The man told ABC7 that in the week after the incident, he kept getting calls from the same numbers and ignored them.

Why it worked

This scam started with a real purchase from the man’s life. He had paid $900 for a cyber protection package six months earlier, and his daughter told ABC7 that all her father could see was that he was getting his $900 back.

In refund scams like this, remote desktop access gives a caller a way to make a fake deposit look real. Moving money from checking to savings inside the victim’s own bank makes the savings balance go up by the exact amount the caller claims to have sent.

Callers in overpayment scams also rely on panic and urgency. When a caller begs for help and says they will be fired for a mistake, a kind person wants to fix the problem right away. The caller walked him through two withdrawals at two branches, and a man arrived at the door within minutes.

What you can do

If someone calls offering a refund for a computer service or subscription, hang up. A refund goes back to your card or arrives as a check, and never needs a code to see your screen. Do not type in a code to let an incoming caller view your computer screen, and never sign in to your bank account while someone is connected to your computer.

Bank of America told ABC7 that customers should watch for red flags such as a call, email, or text that plays with their emotions or pressures them to act right away. If a caller says they accidentally sent you too much money and will lose their job unless you return it in cash, hang up. Call your bank yourself, using the number on the back of your bank card. Or go to a branch and ask a teller whether any outside money arrived.

If you have already given a caller access to your computer or handed over money, disconnect your computer from the internet right away. It is not your fault. Then call your bank using the number on your card and report what happened.

For more information

  1. Online scammers trick 83-year-old Orange County man into handing over $20,000 in person - ABC7 Los Angelesabc7.com

Keep reading

Antivirus Subscription Refund Scam: How It Works

Did you get an email saying your Norton or McAfee subscription renewed for hundreds of dollars? Learn how the antivirus refund scam works and what to do.

How the scam worksTech Support Scams

What Is Remote Access Software?

Remote access software like AnyDesk or TeamViewer lets someone see and control your screen. Learn how it works and why scammers ask you to install it.

DefinitionTech Support Scams