Jeffrey Maas, 77, is a retired human relations professional living in New Jersey1. When he and his wife retired, they planned to travel to Europe, take foreign cruises, leave an inheritance for their adult children, and set up college funds for their two grandchildren. Maas told Business Insider that they had a clear idea of how they wanted to spend their retirement and leave a legacy.
Instead, scammers took $390,000—about half of his life savings—over two days in June 2024.
What happened
On June 5, 2024, Maas received an email saying he had paid $691.05 for Norton Antivirus identity theft protection software. The message did not actually come from Norton. Because he had never ordered the software, Maas called the helpline number printed in the email.
A man using a false name answered and claimed to be a PayPal agent. He told Maas he could refund the money if Maas filled out an online form. Maas gave his bank’s name and the last four digits of his PNC checking and money market accounts. Without Maas knowing, the caller also took control of his computer.
The caller started what he called the refund process, then told Maas he had accidentally deposited $300,000 into Maas’s checking account. Using his access to the computer, the caller showed Maas a falsified PNC bank statement that recorded the $300,000 deposit. Maas told Business Insider that the caller kept saying he would be fired if his mistake was discovered.
The first caller directed Maas to speak with a second man. That second caller claimed the only way to return the $300,000 without facing financial penalties from the IRS was to buy gold.
That same day, Maas went to his regular PNC branch in West Orange, New Jersey. Following the callers’ instructions, he authorized a $300,000 wire transfer to American Coin and Stamp Co., a precious-metal dealer in Clifton, New Jersey. According to a civil lawsuit Maas later filed in the Superior Court of New Jersey, Essex County, he stayed on an open phone line with the caller during the entire bank visit.
According to the lawsuit, the coin dealer received the wire an hour later. Maas drove to Clifton, stayed on the phone with the scammer during the pickup, and brought the gold coins home. Following the caller’s instructions, he waited for a driver to collect them. When a black Nissan with New Jersey plates arrived at his home, Maas put the coins into the back seat through an open window.
The next day, the first caller told Maas the return had worked and offered a $1,000 reward. According to the lawsuit and Maas’s interview with Business Insider, Maas refused the reward and told the caller to leave him alone. The caller insisted on paying $10,000 in compensation because Maas had saved his job.
As Maas filled out a supposed reward form, the caller claimed another mistake had happened: $100,000 had been credited to Maas’s account instead of $10,000. Once again, the caller showed Maas a forged document of his PNC account showing the new deposit and told him to repeat the steps from the day before.
Maas went back to PNC while on an open phone line, withdrew $90,000, and bought more gold coins from the Clifton dealer. This time, a driver in a green Honda with Pennsylvania plates picked up the gold.
A fake billing email
An email claimed Maas was charged $691.05 for Norton software and gave a helpline number to call.
Hidden computer access
While Maas filled out a refund form, the caller quietly took control of his computer.
A forged bank statement
The caller used his computer access to display a fake PNC statement showing a $300,000 overpayment.
Urgency and IRS threats
The caller pleaded that he would lose his job, and a second caller claimed the IRS would penalize Maas unless he returned the money in gold.
A second fake overpayment
The next day, the caller used a reward form to display another forged bank record and take another $90,000.
What happened afterward
Maas told Business Insider that, while still on the phone with the caller, he figured something was not right. After a sleepless night, he reported the crime to the West Orange Police Department and asked PNC to recall the wire transfers. The bank told him the wires could not be undone.
The stress took a severe toll on his health. According to Business Insider, Maas had two episodes of severe fainting that doctors diagnosed as stress-related, spending three days in the hospital each time. He also experienced severe social anxiety.
Police identified the driver of the green Honda as a Pennsylvania man, who was arrested and indicted on a charge of second-degree theft by deception. He pleaded not guilty. At the time of Business Insider’s report, his next court date was July 6, 2026.
Maas also filed a civil lawsuit against PNC, American Coin and Stamp Co., and the Pennsylvania driver, alleging that the bank and the coin dealer ignored warning signs while he was on the phone with the scammers. PNC filed a motion to dismiss on legal grounds and declined to comment to Business Insider on active litigation. The Pennsylvania man denied the allegations in his legal answer. Jeffrey Angello, owner of American Coin, denied any wrongdoing and told Business Insider the lawsuit was “absurd.”
Maas told Business Insider that he came forward publicly so others would take note of his story and recognize these crimes.
Why it worked
Maas told Business Insider that nobody held a gun to his head, adding, “I was trying to do the right thing.” That desire to be fair and honest is what an antivirus refund scam is built to exploit.
First, the email gave Maas a specific reason to call. A $691.05 charge for software he did not buy looked like a billing error that needed to be fixed right away. In a callback scam, the phone number in the email connects directly to the scammers’ call center.
Second, the caller used remote access software, which is a tool that lets someone else see and control your computer screen over the internet. Once someone has control of your computer, they can show you forged documents or edit numbers on the screen so it looks like your bank account holds hundreds of thousands of dollars that do not belong to you.
Third, the callers combined guilt with fear. One caller pleaded that he would be fired if the mistake came out, while the second brought up IRS penalties. Keeping Maas on an open phone line at the bank and the coin shop kept his adrenaline high and gave him no quiet moment to talk things over with his wife or a banker.
What you can do
If you get an email about a charge you do not recognize, do not call the phone number in the message. Instead, check your real bank or credit card statement using the phone number on the back of your card, or by going to the bank in person.
If a caller is on the phone with you and says they put too much money into your account, take these steps in order:
Hang up the phone. You do not owe a polite goodbye to someone pressuring you about money.
Shut down your computer right away. If a caller may have control of your screen, press and hold the physical power button on your computer until the screen goes black, or unplug it from the wall. You can also turn off your home Wi-Fi router. This cuts off their access immediately.
Check your bank balance independently. Call your bank using the number on the back of your debit card, or walk into your local branch without anyone on your cell phone, and ask a banker to check your real balance.
If you have already sent money or handed over gold, call your bank right away to ask if the transfer can be stopped, and file a report with your local police department. Please know that this is not your fault.