Skip to content

How an Illinois Woman Lost $18,400 to a Caller Posing as an FBI Investigator

Gail Walsh of Burbank, Illinois, withdrew $18,400 after a caller claiming to work for the FBI asked for her help checking her bank for counterfeit bills.

Real StoriesNovember 10, 20264 min read

Gail Walsh and her husband live in Burbank, Illinois1. According to CBS News Chicago, they had $18,400 in their bank accounts, which Walsh said was nearly everything they had.

What happened

On August 15, between 11:00 and 11:30 a.m., Walsh answered a phone call from a man who said he was a banking investigator working for the FBI. She told CBS News Chicago that the caller said he was looking into suspicious activity at her bank and asked for her help. He also sent her an email that looked official.

Walsh told the station that the caller appeared to know how much money she had in her accounts. He told her to go to her bank and withdraw $18,400.

The man stayed on the phone with Walsh and guided her through each step as she walked into her Chase branch at 79th Street and Cicero Avenue and took out the cash.

Once she had the bills, the caller told her to read some of the serial numbers printed on them aloud over the phone. After she read them, he told her that some of the bills were counterfeit. He instructed her to drive to another Chase branch at 95th Street and Pulaski Road.

At the second branch, Walsh met a man in a black SUV, who took the cash. The caller on the phone told her that someone from Chase would walk out the front door of the bank right away to hand her “genuine cash”.

No one came out of the bank. Walsh told CBS News Chicago that was the moment it hit her “in a sickening way” that she would never see the money again.

What happened next

Walsh contacted Chase, and she told CBS News Chicago the bank first said there was nothing it could do. She questioned why the bank had not stopped such a large withdrawal. Looking back, she told the reporter she beat herself up because there were places she felt she should have stopped.

After CBS News Chicago contacted Chase, a bank representative said they were working directly with Walsh as she cooperated with law enforcement to pursue the people responsible.

An FBI spokesperson told the station that while the agency could not comment on pending investigations, FBI impersonation scams are on the rise. The FBI advised people to be cautious about giving money or personal details to anyone who contacts them first. Walsh and her husband told CBS News Chicago they hope to recover some of the money and want to warn others to be careful about what they say on the phone.

Why it worked

How the fake bank investigation unfolded
  1. Claiming authority and inside knowledge

    The caller posed as an FBI banking investigator, sent an official-looking email, and appeared to know her account balances.

  2. Staying on the line during the withdrawal

    The caller kept Walsh on the phone the entire time she went into her bank branch to take out $18,400 in cash.

  3. Checking serial numbers to invent a problem

    By having Walsh read the serial numbers on the cash, the caller made it seem like he was checking them before claiming the bills were counterfeit.

  4. Handing off the cash outside a second branch

    Meeting a courier in an SUV outside another Chase branch and promising a bank employee would bring out real bills made the exchange seem tied to the bank.

Scams like this do not rely on a person being careless. They rely on convincing details and steady pressure.

First, the caller appeared to already know how much money Walsh had in her accounts, and he backed up his story with an official-looking email. When someone knows real financial details about you, it is natural to believe they are who they say they are.

Second, the caller framed the withdrawal as part of an official investigation where Walsh was helping catch a problem at her bank. Reading off the serial numbers on the bills made the inspection feel methodical and real.

Finally, the caller stayed on the phone with Walsh the entire time. In this kind of scam, keeping someone on the line prevents them from pausing, calling a family member, or talking openly with a bank teller about why they are taking out the money.

What you can do

If someone calls claiming to be from the FBI, the police, or your bank’s fraud department and asks you to move or withdraw money, hang up right away. Even if they know your account balances or send an official-looking email, do not stay on the line.

  1. Hang up the phone. Ending the call breaks the caller’s control and gives you time to think.

  2. Check the story using a number you trust. Look at the back of your bank card or go to your bank branch in person without anyone on the phone. Ask a teller or manager directly if there is any issue with your account.

  3. Never hand cash to a courier. A real bank or federal agency will never send someone to meet you in a parking lot or vehicle to collect cash.

If you have already withdrawn or handed over money in a situation like this, contact your bank right away to report what happened, and file a report with your local police department and the FBI. It is not your fault.

For more information

  1. Elderly couple in Burbank, Illinois, loses life savings to scammer posing as FBI agentcbsnews.com

Keep reading

What Is Phishing?

Phishing is a scam where someone sends a fake message to steal your passwords, account numbers, or money. Learn what it looks like and how to handle it.

DefinitionText and Email Scams