A woman in Peconic, a hamlet in the town of Southold on Long Island, New York, answered her phone in August 2026 to hear that her grandson was in trouble1. News 12 Long Island and Tu Prensa Local both reported the case from the Southold Town Police account, without naming her. She paid, and when she was told more money was needed, she called the police.
What happened
On August 7, 2026, a man called the woman and said he was her grandson2. According to Southold Town Police, as reported by News 12 Long Island and Tu Prensa Local, the caller claimed he had been in a car crash and had been arrested for driving while intoxicated. He told her he needed $6,720 in cash to pay for his bail.
Next, a second caller spoke with the woman and claimed to be an attorney for her grandson. As part of the arrangement, a courier was sent to her home to pick up the cash.
She handed the $6,720 in cash to the man who came to her residence.
A short time later, she was contacted again and told that more money was needed for the bail. At that point, she stopped and contacted the Southold Town Police Department.
What happened afterward
Southold patrol officers and detectives began an investigation that led them to Nassau County. Working with the Nassau County Police Department, detectives located the man who had gone to the woman’s home to pick up the money.
Police identified him as a 37-year‑old man from New Jersey. According to police, he admitted taking the $6,720, and officers recovered the cash from his vehicle. He was arrested, and Tu Prensa Local noted that the police release did not specify the charges.
Why it worked
Tu Prensa Local reported that police call this the “grandparent scam,” a scheme built to create sudden fear and urgency by making you believe a child, grandchild, or other relative is in custody or facing an emergency.
The emergency call
A caller claimed to be her grandson, saying he was in a car crash, arrested for driving while intoxicated, and needed $6,720 in cash for bail.
The authority figure
A second person called pretending to be a lawyer for the grandson and a courier was sent to pick up the cash.
The home pickup
A man came to her home to collect the $6,720 in cash.
The second demand
Shortly after, she was told more bail money was needed, and she called Southold Town Police.
Using two different callers made the crisis feel official. First, the person pretending to be a family member created the emotional shock. Then, a second person pretending to be a lawyer stepped in to take control and give instructions. Sending a courier to the door also means nobody at a bank or courthouse gets a chance to question the story.
What you can do
Southold Town Police reminded residents that real police departments, courts, and lawyers will never demand immediate cash to keep a loved one from being arrested or to get them out of jail. They also advise never letting anyone who claims to be a courier collect money from your home.
If you get an urgent call like this, take these steps in order:
Hang up the phone. Ending the call gives you a moment to breathe and stops the caller from pressuring you.
Call your relative directly. Police advise checking the story yourself by calling your family member at a phone number you already know is theirs, or by calling another trusted relative. You can also use the same verification steps that help you spot fake family emergency texts, such as agreeing on a family code word ahead of time.
Look up the official police number. If you still have doubts, Southold police say to call the police agency directly using an official number you look up yourself, never a number the caller gives you.
If you have already handed over money or answered a call like this, call your local police department immediately and report the crime to the agencies that handle fraud and scams directed at older adults. Just as the Peconic resident helped detectives recover her money by reporting the second demand, calling right away gives officers the best chance to help. Please know that it is not your fault.