Carol Ann Moritz is a retired woman living in Daytona Beach, Florida1. She had built up a nest egg to pay her bills and enjoy a comfortable life.
What happened
According to Orlando television station WFTV, the call started with a woman who said she worked for Moritz’s bank, Fifth Third Bank. The caller told Moritz that someone in Akron, Ohio, was trying to get into her account and take her money.
Moritz told WFTV that the caller asked for her password to check her identity. Moritz replied that she did not remember her password.
The caller soon brought a man onto the line who said he was her supervisor at Fifth Third Bank. He persuaded Moritz to share her bank card number to confirm who she was.
Then the man posing as a supervisor told her something more alarming. Moritz told WFTV he said the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), the government agency that insures bank deposits, were investigating Fifth Third Bank employees who were stealing from customers.
The callers transferred Moritz to a third person who claimed to be an FBI agent. That caller sent her an official-looking message that described the supposed investigation.
The callers convinced Moritz that she needed to help them catch the dishonest bank employees. To do that, she wired more than $135,000 to a Bank of America account in South Florida. A wire transfer is an electronic way to move money directly from one bank account to another. The callers had her send the money under the cover story that she was buying a business.
The next day, while traveling out of state, Moritz learned that the calls were a scam. She contacted Fifth Third Bank right away.
Fifth Third Bank helped her close the account, open a new one, and report the crime to law enforcement. The bank also tried to get the money back immediately after she called, according to WFTV, but the scammers had already moved the funds.
Moritz told WFTV that the loss took much of her life savings, leaving her with enough to pay her bills but not enough for the life she had planned. She said the experience left her terrified, unable to sleep or eat, and feeling violated in her own home. At the time of WFTV’s report on March 5, 2026, her case with the bank remained open, though the station reported it was unlikely she would get her money back.
Why it worked
This scam did not rely on a single voice or a single claim. It used a team of callers who handed the phone from one person to the next, building a story that explained why Moritz could not trust her own bank.
A warning about a thief
The first caller claimed to be from Fifth Third Bank and warned that someone in Akron, Ohio, was trying to steal her money.
A handoff to a supervisor
When Moritz did not know her password, a second caller posing as a bank supervisor stepped in and got her bank card number.
A claim of an inside investigation
The fake supervisor claimed the FBI and FDIC were investigating dishonest employees inside Fifth Third Bank.
A fake agent and a cover story
A third caller posing as an FBI agent sent an official-looking message and had her wire more than $135,000 to South Florida as if she were buying a business.
Keith Givens, a retired FBI special agent interviewed by WFTV, explained that organized scam groups often use more than one person on a call. He told the station that putting a person on hold and passing them to another speaker makes the call feel like a real office.
Kris Edwards, Head of Fraud Prevention at Fifth Third Bank, told WFTV that bank impersonation scams at the bank tripled from 2024 to 2025. He noted that these callers often spoof the phone number—meaning they fake the caller ID so your screen shows the real bank’s name or number. Edwards told WFTV that the callers always push a strong sense of urgency so you feel you must act right away.
When a caller says bank employees are the ones stealing, it gives a careful person a reason to follow unusual instructions, like giving a cover story for a wire transfer.
What you can do
If someone calls saying your bank account is in danger, or that federal agents need your help catching a thief at your bank, hang up the phone.
Hang up and verify on your own. Retired FBI agent Keith Givens told WFTV that if you get a message from someone you are speaking with on the phone, you should always check it independently. Look up the phone number on the back of your bank card or on a paper statement, or contact a local government office directly to ask if the request is real.
Do not share passwords or card numbers on an incoming call. Even if the caller sounds helpful or transfers you to a supervisor, end the call and dial the bank yourself using a number you know is real.
Report a loss right away. If you have already sent money or shared account details, Givens told WFTV that reporting the fraud to your bank, the FBI, and local police as soon as you learn of it gives you the best chance of getting money back before the scammers move it. It is not your fault.