Skip to content

How a Florida Couple Lost a $38,000 Down Payment to a Fake Wire Email

Matthew and Stefanie Brock wired their $38,805.17 home down payment after receiving fake email instructions that looked like they came from their title company.

Real StoriesNovember 10, 20265 min read

Matthew Brock is a part-owner of a food village in Lake Wales, Florida, that includes a burger spot, a taco stand, a pizza place, and a beer garden1. According to FOX 35 Orlando, he and his wife, Stefanie, were expecting a baby boy and decided to buy a house closer to his work with room for their family to grow.

What happened

The couple found a house they loved and worked out the details with their banks. Early in the buying process, Stefanie sent earnest money—a deposit showing good faith—to the Orlando law firm handling their title trust account. The real wiring instructions from that firm had a warning at the very top saying never to trust wiring instructions sent by email and to always call to confirm.

As the closing date approached, the couple began getting emails that looked like they came from their title company2. FOX 35 Orlando reported that someone had hacked into Stefanie's email and posed as the title company for weeks. According to WKMG ClickOrlando, which cited a Polk County Circuit Court arrest affidavit, the messages came from a spoofed email address—a fake address made to look like a real one—that ended in “.co” instead of “.com”.

In January 2025, the couple received wiring instructions from that address telling them to send $38,805.17 for their down payment. FOX 35 Orlando reported the loss as $38,000 and noted that this second set of instructions did not have the warning at the top. The Brocks wired the money that same day.

Matthew told FOX 35 Orlando that driving to the closing to get the keys was one of the happiest days of their lives. While they were on their way, the real title company called to say the money had never arrived. Stefanie told FOX 35 Orlando that she first thought there had to be a mistake, and that everything sank when they learned it was fraud.

What happened afterward

The Brocks filed fraud reports with their bank, Truist, and with the North Carolina bank that received the wire. They and their title company also reported the theft to the FBI.

According to the arrest affidavit cited by ClickOrlando, Lake Wales Police Department investigators traced the wire to a North Carolina bank account opened nearly two months earlier by a 41-year‑old Maryland man. Police said the man walked into a branch the same day the $38,805.17 arrived and withdrew $33,100. Court records show the bank placed a hold on the rest of the money and denied him access when he drove to a second branch. Investigators said another $485.50 was taken from two ATMs in Charlotte later that day.

FOX 35 Orlando reported in February 2025 that the Secret Service took up the case and got back $5,000 that had not been withdrawn. ClickOrlando later reported that court records indicate the receiving bank closed the account and returned the remaining funds to the Brocks.

In August 2026, police arrested the 41-year‑old Maryland man after Raleigh Police Department officers identified him from bank security footage. According to the affidavit, he was charged with two second-degree felonies—obtaining property by fraud between $20,000 and $50,000, and grand theft between $20,000 and $100,000—and a third-degree felony for fraudulent use of personal identification information. He pleaded not guilty, and a judge allowed him to return to Maryland while awaiting trial.

Why it worked

The message arrived right when the Brocks expected to pay their down payment, in the middle of an ongoing home purchase. Because Stefanie had been emailing with the impersonator for weeks, the final wire request felt like the normal next step in the conversation.

The sender’s address was also designed to pass a quick glance. Leaving the final “m” off “.com” is a tiny visual difference. As Matthew told News 6 in 2025, a homebuyer is not really looking for a single missing consonant in an email address.

Finally, the fake instructions left off the warning header that had appeared on the real firm’s earlier earnest money document. Without that reminder on the page, nothing prompted the couple to stop and call before going to the bank.

What you can do

Before you wire money for a home purchase or any large transaction, call the company to read back the account and routing numbers. In statements to FOX 35 Orlando, both Truist and the Brocks’ title company advised buyers to verify all wire instructions directly with a trusted professional using a phone number from the company’s website or official paperwork, not a number listed in the email.

The title company also advised being careful with last-minute changes to payment details or urgent requests to wire money quickly. Taking ten minutes to make a phone call to a number you know is real breaks the scammer’s hold, even if they are watching your email.

If you have already sent a wire transfer and suspect fraud, call your bank right away and ask them to stop or recall the wire transfer. It is not your fault. Next, call the bank that received the money so they can freeze the account. Finally, report the crime to your local police department and the FBI.

For more information

  1. Couple hoping to save others from the fate they suffered: $38,000 lost in a home escrow wire fraud | FOX 35 Orlandofox35orlando.com
  2. Man charged with stealing nearly $39K down payment in real estate schemeclickorlando.com

Keep reading

What Is Phishing?

Phishing is a scam where someone sends a fake message to steal your passwords, account numbers, or money. Learn what it looks like and how to handle it.

DefinitionText and Email Scams