Skip to content

How an Orlando Couple Lost $7,500 to a Spoofed Call From Their ‘Bank’

Carmen and William Evans of Orlando lost more than $7,500 after a caller whose number showed up as Wells Fargo asked for a text code.

Real StoriesNovember 10, 20264 min read

Carmen Evans and her husband, William, live in Orlando, Florida1. Carmen worked a part‑time job, received Social Security, and used a payment app called Cash App for small personal expenses and money for her grandchildren.

What happened

According to WKMG ClickOrlando, Carmen received a phone call with a caller ID that showed Wells Fargo, a bank she recognized. Caller ID is the display on your phone screen that shows who is calling. A man on the line said his name was “Michael” and that he worked in the bank’s fraud department. He told her there were questionable charges on her account.

The caller knew who Carmen was without her giving her name. He listed recent purchases at Walmart and Sam’s Club that she recognized. Then he brought up a $3,000 charge that she had not made.

Next, the caller told Carmen she would receive a text message with a code and asked her to read it back to him during the phone call.

What the caller says

You're going to be getting some text with the code. Just make sure you repeat the code to me.

Incoming call

Wells Fargo

mobile

Red flags on this call

Carmen told WKMG that she shared the codes because she thought she was speaking with Wells Fargo and helping to protect her money.

When Carmen tried to log in to her bank accounts afterward, she could not get in. She and William drove to a Wells Fargo branch for help. William told WKMG that while they were standing in the branch, a bank employee told them that activity was happening in their accounts right then. William said he told the employee to stop it because the employee could see it was not them.

The couple later learned that money had been moved between their accounts and sent out through Cash App using Carmen’s linked Wells Fargo debit card. In total, the couple told WKMG they lost more than $7,500 across their accounts. That included about $3,000 in savings, Carmen’s Social Security payment, and paychecks from her part‑time job.

What happened afterward

The missing money was what Carmen and William needed to pay their bills. Carmen told WKMG they had to take out loans to cover their expenses. With rent and a car payment due, they also had to ask their children for financial help. William said they were still struggling to catch up even after their next checks arrived.

Carmen disputed the transfers with the bank, which means she formally asked the bank to investigate and return the stolen money, but she had not gotten the funds back as of WKMG’s October 27, 2026 report. She deleted Cash App, and the couple said they were working to move their accounts to another bank. Carmen told the station she shared what happened to educate others so they would not have to go through the same thing.

Why it worked

Every detail at the start of the call matched what a careful person would expect from a real bank alert:

  • The screen showed the bank’s name. Scammers can fake caller ID so your phone displays the real name and phone number of your bank. This trick is called spoofing.

  • The caller knew real purchases. Because the caller already knew Carmen’s name and her real trips to Walmart and Sam’s Club, he sounded like someone looking at her actual bank screen.

  • The fake $3,000 charge created urgency. Hearing about a large charge she did not make gave Carmen a clear reason to cooperate right away to stop it.

  • The text code looked like normal security. Banks send one‑time codes by text message to prove it is really you logging in or approving a change. When someone already has your login details or card information, that code is the final key they need to take over the account.

What you can do

If you get a call from someone claiming to be your bank’s fraud department:

  1. Hang up the phone. Do not trust the name on your caller ID screen, even if the caller knows your name or recent purchases.

  2. Call the number on the back of your bank card. Look at your physical debit or credit card and dial that number yourself. Do not call back a number the caller gives you.

  3. Keep text codes to yourself. Treat a security code sent to your phone like a password. Only type it in yourself when you are the one logging in.

If you already shared a code or noticed missing money, call your bank and any linked payment apps right away using the number on your card. This is not your fault. Ask them to freeze your accounts and dispute the charges, change your passwords, and file a report with your local police and the Federal Trade Commission.

For more information

  1. ‘Read me the code’: A fake bank call cost an Orlando couple more than $7,500clickorlando.com

Keep reading

Fake Phone Calls That Look Like Your Bank

Caller ID can show your bank’s real name and number on a scam call. Learn how to spot a fake bank call and what to do if you shared a code.

How the scam worksPhone Call Scams