Judith Boivin is a retired psychotherapist in Rockville, Maryland1. According to The Washington Post, she spent her career helping people as a registered nurse and a licensed clinical social worker. She provided trauma counseling after natural disasters, volunteered at a hospice, and started an outreach center for children in Belize. After she closed her therapy practice in 2004, she worked as a companion for people with dementia.
What happened
In September 2023, Judith was driving her husband to a doctor’s appointment when her phone rang. Her caller ID, the screen that shows who is calling, displayed “Rockville Police Department.” It was the second call from local police in two days, so she answered.
A man on the line said he would transfer her to the head of the city police. A second man came on the phone and told her that her Social Security number had been flagged in a crime. He said she had to clear things up or face charges. Because it was a federal case, he transferred her to a third man who claimed to be an FBI agent.
The third caller said a drug cartel had used her Social Security number to open several bank accounts. Then he made a specific request on the phone.
What the caller says
You don't have a profile that would indicate your guilt in this case. Would you be willing to be an asset?
Incoming call
FBI Agent
mobile
Red flags on this call
Judith told him she would help if she could be of assistance. She believed that by clearing her name, she would also be helping catch the criminals.
The caller gave his name as FBI special agent Wayne A. Jacobs and provided a case number, CP920-416. Judith told The Washington Post that she searched the names and phone numbers online. She found that a real Wayne A. Jacobs ran the criminal and cyber division of the FBI field office in Washington, and the phone numbers matched.
From mid-September through mid-December 2023, the caller phoned her twice a day, at 9 a.m. and 6 p.m. Each time, he asked first whether she was alone. He told her to keep her involvement secret from everyone, including her husband, so she would not put the investigation at risk. They even agreed on a code word—her favorite color, beige—so she could ask callers to prove they were calling from his office.
Soon, the caller told her that the cartel had enough of her personal information to put her bank accounts at risk. At his request, she filled out a form listing all of her savings and where they were held. He told her to take her retirement savings out of Morgan Stanley, the firm that had managed her investments for 30 years. He instructed her not to tell the staff at Morgan Stanley the real reason for the withdrawals.
He sent her an email with an official FBI seal and a document with a U.S. State Department seal. The document assigned her a government “safety locker” number, SFTY‑LCKR 196-00-706, and promised her money would be returned after a trial. Following his instructions, she moved her funds to checking accounts at several banks in Maryland and withdrew cash. On December 13, she texted the caller that she had $20,500 in cash on hand and asked if he wanted a drop that day.
Over those three months, Judith handed over $595,000 in cash. In an interview with WMAR-2 News, she said the loss was the totality of her IRAs and savings2. She told WMAR-2 News that despite warnings from her financial institution, she believed she was helping investigators protect her finances, and she did not realize it was a scam until the Maryland Office of the Attorney General contacted her months later.
Why it worked
The callers were not with the police or the FBI. According to The Washington Post, they used technology to manipulate the phone numbers so the calls looked like they came from local police and federal offices. When Judith did the careful thing and looked up the agent’s name and phone number online, the results matched real government records.
The caller also knew a great deal about Judith’s life. She told WMAR-2 News that the caller knew she had lived in Mexico, had traveled to other countries, and knew her education history. She later realized much of that detail had likely come from her profile on LinkedIn, a professional networking website.
There were small clues hidden in the paperwork. The emails from the caller carried the FBI seal, but the email address ended in “.com” instead of the “.gov” used by real U.S. government agencies. The caller also used a tool that remotely erased his side of their text message conversations from her phone.
After the scam came to light, Judith connected with two other Maryland women through an AARP fraud victim support group, according to WMAR-2 News. The three women now meet once a month to support each other and speak to the public about how these crimes work.
What you can do
Real law enforcement agencies and government offices will never ask you to withdraw cash, wire money, or move your savings into a locker or another account to protect it. They will never demand that you keep an investigation a secret from your spouse or your bank.
If you get a call like this, take these steps in order:
Hang up the phone. Do not stay on the line to let the caller transfer you to another department or agency.
Talk to someone you trust right away, such as a spouse, a family member, or your bank manager. Breaking the secrecy stops the caller’s control.
If you want to check whether a call was real, find the agency’s phone number yourself on an official website ending in .gov, and call that number directly.
If you have already handed over money or financial information, call your bank or investment firm right away to tell them what happened and ask if any transfers can be stopped. Please know that this is not your fault. Then report the crime to your local police department, the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov. You can also call the free AARP Fraud Watch Network helpline at 877‑908‑3360 for support and guidance.