Doreen Duhancik and her husband lived in Ansonia, Connecticut1. According to NBC Connecticut, which reported on her experience in July 2015, she felt fear and uncertainty about owing money to the Internal Revenue Service, or IRS.
What happened
Duhancik and her husband saw a television commercial from a tax relief company. The ad suggested the company could help settle IRS tax debt for pennies on the dollar. She told NBC Connecticut that her husband kept seeing the commercial repeat the words “we help” and asked her to call.
The commercial included fine print on the screen with a disclaimer about what viewers could actually expect:
Tax10,000
Results are not typical. You may not meet IRS eligibility requirements for this program. Even if you do, you should not expect to reduce your taxes by this much.
Red flags in this video
Promise of settling tax debt for pennies on the dollar
Small-print disclaimer that results are not typical and eligibility may not be met
Disclaimer stating the advertiser does not provide tax relief services and only refers callers to another company
Another disclaimer in the commercial stated that the advertiser did not provide tax relief services itself, and only referred callers to a company that helped people negotiate with the IRS.
Duhancik called the number to ask questions about the offer. The person on the phone told her the service would cost about $1,700. During the call, she gave the representative her bank account information.
She told NBC Connecticut that she knew right away there was no way she could pay that amount, and she never signed the paperwork giving the company legal authority to start any work.
Days later, a second company withdrew a first payment of $875 from her bank account. The withdrawal emptied her checking and savings accounts and left her with a balance of negative $124. According to NBC Connecticut, the company did not do any work for her.
When Duhancik called the tax relief company back to ask for her money, she was transferred from person to person. Nobody had answers about her funds, and she told the station that she was hung up on.
How she got her money back
Duhancik contacted NBC Connecticut’s consumer team. After the station called the company behind the advertiser’s website, a third company called her and refunded her money. NBC Connecticut noted that three companies now held her personal information.
Why it worked
Tax attorney Fred L. Baker told NBC Connecticut that the IRS has collection tools that no other creditor has. It can file legal claims against property, known as liens, without going to court, and it can take wages or assets.
Companies that advertise tax relief on television use that worry to get phone calls. The spoken words in the commercial promised help and big reductions, while the truth was hidden in fine print on the screen. The fine print admitted that the advertiser was only a referral service, also known as a lead generator.
Once a caller shares bank routing and account numbers over the phone, the referral company can pass those details to other businesses. As Baker told NBC Connecticut, it is hard to verify the credentials of these companies, and hard to reach anyone when something goes wrong.
What you can do
Never give your bank account number or routing number over the phone when you are only asking questions about a service. Keep your banking details private until you have reviewed a written contract and decided to sign it.
Contact the IRS directly or visit its official website at IRS.gov. As NBC Connecticut reported, the IRS has an official program called an Offer in Compromise that allows people who meet strict rules to settle their tax debt for less than they owe. You can apply for this program on your own without paying a middleman. A caller who says they are the IRS and demands payment is one of the fake IRS phone calls that scammers make.
Look for free, trustworthy tax help in your community. The IRS runs Low Income Taxpayer Clinics that help people who qualify with IRS problems for free or a small fee2.
If you hire a professional, research the company first.