Skip to content

How an Illinois Customer Lost Over $40,000 to a Spoofed Call From Her ‘Bank’

Jennifer Lichthardt of Elgin, Illinois, lost over $40,000 after callers using her bank’s number read her exact balance and told her to move her money.

Real StoriesNovember 10, 20264 min read

Jennifer Lichthardt lives in Elgin, Illinois, a suburb northwest of Chicago1. According to an ABC7 Chicago report on May 5, 2026, she answered a phone call that appeared to come directly from her bank, Chase.

What happened

Lichthardt told ABC7 Chicago that the caller ID on her phone showed the exact telephone number printed on the back of her Chase debit card, and the screen said “Chase fraud department.”

The people on the call claimed to be from Chase and from the FBI. They told Lichthardt that Chase employees were getting into customers’ accounts. One caller claiming to be with the FBI gave her an agent number.

The callers also read Lichthardt her Chase account number. She told ABC7 Chicago that they had her account balance “down to the penny.”

According to ABC7 Chicago, the callers convinced Lichthardt to move close to $40,000 from her regular Chase account into what they described as a new “secured” Chase account at her local branch. They also convinced her to move thousands of dollars more to another online bank.

The next morning, Lichthardt realized she had been scammed and reported the incidents to local authorities and the FBI. By then, the money was gone. Chase told ABC7 Chicago that the funds were taken out of the scammer’s account on the same day they were deposited.

Lichthardt told the station that she felt “financially violated.” According to ABC7 Chicago, she did not get a refund from her bank because she had been convinced to move the money herself. She told the station that federal authorities are helping to track down the criminals, and that she hopes to get her money back. Chase told ABC7 Chicago that it is cooperating with law enforcement.

Why it worked

How the spoofed bank and FBI call worked
  1. Faking the bank phone number

    The callers made their phone number match the real number on the back of the Chase debit card.

  2. Reading real account details

    The callers read out her real account number and her exact balance down to the penny.

  3. Claiming inside fraud and FBI involvement

    They claimed bank employees were accessing accounts and brought in a fake FBI agent with an agent number.

  4. Rushing a transfer to a safe account

    They convinced her to move her money into a supposed secured account.

Every detail a careful customer might check during an incoming call pointed toward the callers being real.

First, the phone screen showed the real number from the back of her debit card. Scammers do this using caller ID spoofing, which is a way of making a phone display any number or name the caller chooses.

Second, the callers knew private details that only a bank should know: her full account number and her exact balance. According to the FBI and other experts cited by ABC7 Chicago, criminals can get banking details from the dark web—a hidden part of the internet where stolen information is sold—or from stolen paper trash. Once criminals have those details, they may call a bank’s automated phone system to get a customer’s exact balance or recent transactions.

Third, the callers claimed to be the FBI. Robert Richardson, a special agent with the FBI Chicago Field Office, told ABC7 Chicago that when someone calls pretending to be the FBI, the person answering thinks they are in trouble and gets frazzled. The criminal then rushes them more so they make last-minute decisions.

What you can do

Chase told ABC7 Chicago that banks and legitimate companies will never ask you by phone, text, or the internet to move money or give access to your computer or bank accounts.

If you get a call from your bank or from law enforcement saying your account is at risk:

  1. Hang up the phone. End the call, even if the caller ID matches the number on your card, and even if the caller reads your account number or balance.

  2. Call the bank yourself. Dial the phone number printed on the back of your debit or credit card, or visit your local branch in person. Calling that number yourself reaches the real bank.

  3. Ignore requests to move money. Never transfer money into a new account or send it through a payment app because a caller told you to protect it.

If you have already moved money after a call like this, call your bank right away using the number on the back of your card, and report the crime to your local police and to the FBI. What happened is not your fault.

For more information

  1. Sophisticated banking spoof callers drain local customers' accounts ...abc7chicago.com

Keep reading

Fake Phone Calls That Look Like Your Bank

Caller ID can show your bank’s real name and number on a scam call. Learn how to spot a fake bank call and what to do if you shared a code.

How the scam worksPhone Call Scams