Skip to content

How an 86-Year‑Old Grandmother Lost $10,000 to a Fake Grandson Bail Call

A Cincinnati grandmother withdrew $10,000 in cash after a caller posing as a public defender said her grandson was in jail and drove her to the bank.

Real StoriesNovember 10, 20265 min read

An 86-year‑old grandmother in the Mount Washington neighborhood of Cincinnati, Ohio, raised five children and was careful with her savings1. According to Cincinnati television station WLWT, her family said she rarely withdrew more than $1,000 from her bank account. Her daughter, Margie Massie, told WLWT that her mother is hard of hearing, has dementia, and does not drive.

In late July 2026, a phone call about her grandson led her to withdraw $10,000 in cash.

What happened

On a Wednesday in late July 2026, the woman received a phone call at her home. Massie told WLWT that the caller said her mother’s grandson had been arrested after getting into a car accident. The accident had never happened.

According to WLWT, a man posing as a public defender said her grandson’s lawyer needed $8,500 to get him out of jail2. The caller also told her not to tell anyone what had happened.

Because the grandmother does not drive, she had no way to get to the bank on her own. She later told police and her daughter that a man wearing a nice suit and driving a black sedan came to her house and picked her up.

He drove her to the Fifth Third Bank branch in Mount Washington. Before she went inside, the scammer coached her on what to say if the bank asked questions.

At the counter, she asked to withdraw $10,000 in cash. Kris Edwards, the head of fraud prevention at Fifth Third Bank, told WLWT that the bank teller asked why she needed such a large amount of cash. She gave the answer the scammer had told her to give: that the money was for a wedding gift.

She took the $10,000 in cash, handed it to the man, and he drove her back home.

The next day, the woman called her daughter. Massie told WLWT that her mother sounded upset and said she could not tell anyone, but that something awful had happened. When her mother explained that a man had picked her up and driven her to the bank to get bail money for her grandson, Massie broke the news to her mother that it was a scam.

What happened afterward

Massie went to the bank that day and asked them to place a flag on her mother’s account so she cannot withdraw money unless one of her five children is with her.

Massie’s family questioned why a $10,000 cash withdrawal did not trigger extra checks, since her mother rarely took out more than $1,000. Edwards told WLWT that banks have to balance spotting warning signs with letting customers access their own money.

According to WLWT, Cincinnati police are investigating the case and looking for the man who drove her, whom the grandmother described as having dark hair and a mole on his face. Fifth Third Bank told WLWT that it is reviewing the case and has video footage of the withdrawal, including the vehicle.

Why it worked

This kind of scam targets a grandparent’s care for their family. As Massie told WLWT, few things are more upsetting than hearing that a grandchild is in trouble.

Edwards told WLWT that scammers rely on three tactics in cases like this:

  • Personal details. Scammers look up family names and city details on social media and on the dark web, a hidden part of the internet where stolen personal details are traded. They also use spoofed phone numbers—numbers changed to look like a local call on your caller ID screen—so the call feels real.

  • Urgency and secrecy. Callers push you to act fast to help a relative, while telling you to keep the emergency a secret so you do not call another family member to check the story.

  • Coaching you to lie to the bank. Bank tellers are trained to ask questions when a customer takes out a large amount of cash. Callers know this, so they give the person a cover story—such as buying a wedding gift—to stop the teller from stepping in.

How the fake bail call unfolded
  1. The urgent call

    A caller said her grandson was arrested after a car accident and told her to keep it secret.

  2. The fake lawyer

    A man posing as a public defender said her grandson needed bail money right away.

  3. The ride to the bank

    A man in a suit picked her up at her home and drove her to her bank branch.

  4. The coached cover story

    When the teller asked about the $10,000 withdrawal, she gave the wedding gift story the scammer told her to use.

What you can do

If you get an urgent phone call or message claiming a grandchild or relative is in jail or in the hospital, pause before you act.

  1. Hang up and call a family member. Massie told WLWT that families should agree to call another relative before taking any money out of the bank for an emergency. Use a phone number you already have saved, not one the caller gives you, whenever a caller says a loved one needs bail money or you get a fake family emergency text message.

  2. Never let a caller tell you what to say to your bank. If someone on the phone tells you to make up a story for the bank teller, such as saying the cash is for a wedding gift, hang up. A real lawyer or court official will never ask you to lie to your bank.

  3. Never get into a car with someone sent by a caller. Real public defenders, lawyers, and courts do not send people to your home to pick up cash or drive you to the bank.

  4. Ask your bank about account safeguards. As WLWT reported, you can ask your bank what protections they offer for large withdrawals, such as requiring a trusted family member to be notified or present.

For more information

  1. 86-year-old woman with dementia scammed out of thousandswlwt.com
  2. Fifth Third Bank's head of fraud prevention discusses scam that ...wlwt.com

Keep reading