Elaine is a retired executive1. Before the coronavirus pandemic, she had never used online banking. When calls to her bank’s phone lines left her waiting for hours, she decided to try banking online.
According to Birmingham Live, which reported on her June 2022 interview on the BBC One programme Dirty Rotten Scammers, Elaine lost £30,000 after a caller claiming to represent BT convinced her to let him connect to her computer2.
What happened
During the pandemic, Elaine was self-isolating alone at home. The day after her first attempt at online banking, she received a phone call from a man claiming to be from BT Internet. He told her that she had made a bank transfer the day before and that someone had broken through her computer’s firewall, a security system that blocks unauthorized access.
What the caller says
This is BT Internet – I see that you made a bank transfer yesterday and I need to let you know that someone has broken your firewall
Incoming call
Man claiming to represent BT
mobile
Red flags on this call
Elaine confirmed to the caller that she had made a transfer the previous day. The caller then offered to pass her to a technical department.
The man convinced Elaine to grant him remote access, which is a way for someone else to view and control a computer from afar. He claimed he was securing her devices. Instead, according to Birmingham Live, he spent two days remotely downloading malware, which is malicious software designed to steal data or give criminals control, onto her laptop.
Using that access, the fraudster stole £30,000 from her bank account, which amounted to 20 years of her savings.
What happened afterward
Elaine discovered the theft when she checked her bank account. According to Birmingham Live, she said she felt “really humiliated” and was too embarrassed to tell her family and friends for more than two weeks. She said she could not sleep at night because she kept hearing the caller’s voice in her head.
Elaine later got the £30,000 back, though she told the programme that the experience changed her outlook and left her trusting no one.
During the BBC programme, ethical hackers working with presenters Michelle and Mavis Ackerley found Elaine’s main password exposed online3. Her information had been compromised in five data breaches over six years.
Why it worked
Elaine described the situation to the BBC as a “perfect storm of circumstances”.
First, the timing matched what she had just done. She had tried online banking for the very first time the day before the call. When the caller stated that she had made a bank transfer the previous day, his claim matched a real event.
Second, the caller’s manner built confidence. Elaine said that he was patient, intelligent, and seemed to know what he was doing.
Third, she was self-isolating alone during the pandemic. Scams like this work best when nobody is nearby to ask, “Does this sound right?”
What you can do
Speaking on the BBC programme, cyber safety expert Oz Alashe said that if someone calls asking for access to your computer, you should not give it to them. He said no one will fault you for hanging up, looking up your service provider’s official phone number online, and calling them back directly.
If a caller or a message asks you to share your screen, hang up and follow how to end a callback scam. If you have already allowed someone remote access to your computer or shared your banking details, take these steps in order:
Disconnect your computer from the internet by turning off Wi‑Fi or unplugging the network cable. Remember that it is not your fault.
Call your bank right away using the number on the back of your bank card.
Run reputable anti-virus software on any device that may have been accessed, as Alashe recommended on the programme.
Change your passwords from a different, clean device. The programme’s presenters also recommended using a password manager, which is a tool that creates and stores strong passwords, and checking a breach-alert website to see if your email or passwords have been exposed in past data breaches.