Barry Heitin is a 76-year‑old retired lawyer who lives in Arlington, Virginia1. He has three adult children and worked with the same financial adviser for more than 20 years.
In the fall of 2023, callers convinced him that he was helping the federal government protect his savings and catch a ring of thieves. According to The New York Times, the nearly three-month deception cost him about $740,000, which was almost all of his retirement savings.
What happened
In September, Heitin could not log in to his 401(k) retirement account. Several days later, he got into the account, and the screen changed. It showed the logo of his investment firm and told him to call the fraud department. He called the phone number on the screen.
A man answered and said he was a fraud investigation officer with the firm. He told Heitin that someone was trying to get into his retirement account. The caller also named a large bank where Heitin held an individual retirement account (IRA), a checking account, and a savings account. The caller said that money was at risk too.
That man connected Heitin to a second caller, who said he worked at Heitin’s checking bank. This caller claimed that two $10,000 transactions had been made from the account to buy illegal material from a website in China. He asked Heitin several questions about China. Heitin had never been to China and had not bought anything there.
The caller told him that financial institutions often work with the federal government on cases like this. A third caller then got on the line. He said he was with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), gave a badge number, and said the government could protect Heitin’s money by moving it into a “federal locker”.
Heitin told The New York Times what the callers kept saying to him on the phone:
What the caller says
This is a big case and we are going to stop a whole ring of people.
Incoming call
Unknown caller
mobile
Red flags on this call
Claimed to be a federal investigation
Asked the victim to keep the call secret, including from family
Used urgency to push quick action
Told him his bank and adviser could not be trusted
Asked him to move savings to a federal locker
Heitin agreed to help. He told The New York Times that he gave the callers access to his computer. His computer screen showed a map with moving lines, which the callers used to describe fake thieves.
The callers told him not to tell anyone about the investigation, including his children. They phoned him every morning and evening. One caller walked him through each step as he withdrew $113,000 from his checking and savings accounts. He moved the money using ATMs, wire transfers to other accounts, and Bitcoin, which is a type of digital currency.
Next, the callers told him to move his retirement money. When his bank asked why, Heitin first said he was buying property in Canada. The bank checked and found the property was not for sale. He then said he needed the money to buy gold, and the bank asked him to come into a branch. Before that visit, the callers told Heitin that his personal information had leaked through that branch and that his longtime financial adviser was on a watch list. Heitin did not get his money at that bank.
On the callers’ advice, he moved his IRA, which held about $834,000, to a different financial firm. That firm allowed the transfer. He emptied the account in under two weeks and moved the money into bank accounts.
Heitin then withdrew cash from two bank branches, $5,000 at a time. When banks asked questions, he wired money to a gold dealer in New York. The gold dealer warned him about another customer who had been drawn into buying gold for a scammer. Heitin bought gold three times for roughly $416,000 in total. Each time, he placed the gold in a brown paper bag and left it in the back seat of a car that pulled up to his building.
In late November, a detective in New Jersey called Heitin. Police had found a paper receipt for gold with his name and address in a car. The detective told him he was probably the victim of a scam. Heitin later met with two FBI agents at his daughter’s house and learned he was one of at least seven victims in a scheme based in India.
Beyond the roughly $740,000 he lost, the retirement withdrawals left him owing nearly $285,000 in federal and state taxes. As of July 2024, his lawyer, Robert Rabinowitz, was working to recover some of the money and planned to ask the IRS for an individual tax ruling.
Why it worked
This kind of scam relies on authority, fear, and isolation rather than a lack of care by the victim.
A screen prompt with a real logo
After days of login trouble, a message showing the logo of his 401(k) provider told him to call a fraud number.
Knowing where he banked
The first caller named the real bank where Heitin kept his checking, savings, and IRA accounts.
A frightening accusation
A second caller claimed illegal purchases had been made from his account, creating a reason to involve federal agents.
Daily contact and secrecy
Callers phoned morning and night, told him not to tell his children, and claimed his bank branch and financial adviser were under suspicion.
First, the scam started when Heitin was already trying to log in to his real retirement account, and the message on his screen showed his provider’s logo. When the first caller knew the name of his other bank, the call sounded official.
Second, the callers used a disturbing accusation about illegal purchases from China. When an honest person hears that a crime is tied to their bank account, their natural instinct is to clear their name and help investigators.
Third, the callers cut him off from the people who could have given him a second opinion. They told him to keep the case secret from his children. When his bank asked questions, the callers told him that the bank branch had leaked his information and that his financial adviser of 20 years was on a watch list. That turned every warning from his bank or the gold dealer into what looked like part of the cover-up.
What you can do
Real banks, investment firms, and federal agencies like the IRS never ask you to withdraw cash, buy gold, or use Bitcoin to protect your money.
If someone on the phone says your accounts are in danger or asks for access to your computer:
Hang up the phone. Even if the caller gives a badge number or knows where you bank, ending the call is the safest first step.
Talk to someone you trust. If a caller tells you not to tell your family or your financial adviser, call a family member or your adviser right away.
Call your bank or investment firm directly using a number from a paper statement.
If you have already given a caller access to your computer or moved money at their request, disconnect your computer from the internet or turn it off so the caller can no longer reach it. Remember that it is not your fault. Then call your bank and investment firms using the numbers on your paper statements to ask them to freeze your accounts, and report it to your local police, to the FBI at ic3.gov and to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.