When a 76-year‑old man in Rochester, Minnesota, saw a bill for computer software he no longer used, he did what any careful person would do with an unexpected charge: he called the phone number on the statement to get it taken care of1.
Over the days that followed, people posing as employees of the antivirus company McAfee convinced him to send three wire transfers totaling $168,000, according to reporting by ABC 6 News and the Rochester Post Bulletin2. Neither news outlet named the man, and both reported the facts from Rochester Police Capt. Casey Moilanen.
What happened
According to ABC 6 News, the scam began on August 8, 2022, when the man received a fake statement saying he had been billed for an automatic renewal of McAfee antivirus software. The Post Bulletin reported the bill was for $399 for a product he no longer had, while ABC 6 News reported the amount as $400.
The statement listed a phone number at the bottom for questions. The man called the number and reached someone claiming to work for McAfee.
The caller promised to refund the charge and told the man he needed to download a program onto his computer. That program was remote access software, a tool that lets another person view and control your computer screen from far away. The man downloaded the program.
Once connected, the caller told the man a mistake had been made. According to ABC 6 News, the caller sent a fake notification and claimed to have accidentally sent $40,000 directly to the man’s Wells Fargo bank account. To fix the supposed overpayment, the caller asked the man to wire $39,500 to an address provided by the scammers. A wire transfer is a direct electronic payment from one bank account to another that is very difficult to reverse once sent. The man wired the money.
Next, the man spoke with a second person who claimed to be the first caller’s manager. This person told him the first wire transfer had not gone through, leaving the company still short $40,000. They asked him to wire another $39,000 to Hong Kong, and he did.
After that transfer, the callers told the man that another $40,000 was hidden in his bank account and would be revealed if he sent more money. They told him that if he wired $90,000, they would send him $200,000 to pay him back for the $90,000 and the two earlier transfers, plus roughly $30,000 extra for his trouble. They also promised to send him a free iPad.
The man sent the $90,000, bringing his total loss to $168,000.
Moilanen told ABC 6 News he did not know the exact moment the man realized the calls and transfers were a scam, though police suspected it happened when the man checked his bank account and saw that the promised transfers from the callers had never arrived. The iPad never arrived either, and the man reported the crime to the Rochester Police Department.
A fake renewal bill arrives
The scammers sent a false McAfee statement for about $400 with a phone number to call with questions.
Remote software is installed
To issue the refund, the caller told the man to download a program that gave the caller control of his computer.
A false $40,000 overpayment
The caller sent a fake notification claiming $40,000 was put into his Wells Fargo account by mistake and asked him to wire back $39,500.
A manager steps in
A second caller claimed the first wire failed and asked him to wire $39,000 to Hong Kong, then $90,000 more to unlock a $200,000 reimbursement.
Why it worked
First, the scammers did not call the man out of the blue. They sent a fake bill for $399 or $400 for a product he knew he no longer used. Because he initiated the phone call using the number on the statement, it felt like he was reaching a real billing department.
Second, once someone has remote access to a computer, they can put false notifications on the screen. In this case, ABC 6 News reported that the scammer sent a false notification to back up the claim that $40,000 had gone into the man’s Wells Fargo account. Most people do not want to keep $39,500 that was sent to them by mistake.
After the first wire, the callers brought in a second person who said the wire had failed. Later they promised a $200,000 reimbursement if he sent $90,000 more.
What you can do
Speaking with the Post Bulletin and ABC 6 News, Capt. Moilanen advised residents never to allow anyone to download a program that controls their computer unless they are certain of who they are dealing with and trust them.
If you get a bill or renewal notice for something you did not order, take these steps in order:
Do not call the phone number on an unexpected bill or email. This is the antivirus subscription refund scam, a kind of callback scam where the number leads to the scammers.
Check your real bank or credit card statement yourself—by logging in the way you normally do or by calling the number on the back of your card—to see if any charge actually happened.
Never install software that lets a caller see or control your screen to process a refund.
Never wire money to fix an overpayment.
If you have already let someone onto your computer or sent a wire, disconnect your computer from the internet. It is not your fault. Call your bank on the number on your card and ask whether the wire can be recalled, and report what happened.