A scammer victim list, which criminals call a “sucker list,” is a record of people who answered or paid a scammer in the past. Criminals buy, sell, and trade these lists so other scammers can contact the same people again.
If you are getting new calls or messages after a past scam, do not pay anyone who promises to get your lost money back. Being on one of these lists is not your fault, and knowing how they work helps you spot the next approach right away.
How a name gets on a victim list
You do not have to lose money to end up on a victim list. Scammers send out thousands of test calls, texts, and emails to see who answers. If you reply to a message, click a link, or stay on the phone with a caller, the scammer marks your phone number or email address as active.
If you did lose money or share personal details, the scammer writes down more information. A typical record on a victim list includes:
Your name, phone number, email address, and home address.
The kind of scam that worked, such as a prize offer or a fake investment.
How much money you sent and how you paid, such as by wire transfer (an electronic bank‑to-bank payment) or gift card.
Brief notes from the first scammer about what convinced you to trust them.
The first contact
A scammer sends out thousands of calls, texts, or emails and records who replies or pays.
Building the record
The scammer writes down your contact details, what story they used, and any money you sent.
Selling the list
The scammer sells or trades this list to other criminal groups for a profit.
The second approach
A new scammer uses those notes to call you, often pretending to be an official who can get your money back.
Why it matters
When a new scammer buys a victim list, they already know your name and what happened to you. They use those facts to sound like someone you can trust, which is a tactic called spear phishing.
The most common follow-up trap is a recovery scam. A caller or emailer claims to be from a government agency, a law firm, or a consumer group. They say they found your name on an official list of fraud victims and can get your money back1. Between February 2023 and February 2024, victims reported losing over $9.9 million to recovery scams.
Before they return your money, they ask you to pay an upfront fee, a tax, or a retainer2. Or they ask for your bank account number to deposit the refund. No real government agency or company will ever call you to offer a refund for a fee.
What the caller says
Hello, we have your file from the fraud you reported earlier this year.
We recovered your funds and are holding them in an escrow account.
To release the money back to your bank, you just need to pay a small processing fee.
Incoming call
US Refund Task Force
phone number removed
Red flags on this call
Scammers on the list may also try a different angle. If the list says you entered a sweepstakes, they may call with a new prize. If you lost money in a long-term investment scam, they may pretend to be a foreign bank holding your funds.
What to do
You cannot ask criminals to erase your name from their files. Instead, you can make your contact details useless to them and protect your accounts.
Hang up on anyone offering to recover lost money. Never pay a fee, tax, or charge to get a refund, and never share your bank account numbers with someone who calls you.
Stop replying to unknown messages. Do not answer texts from strangers, even to say “stop.” Do not click links in unexpected emails. Move suspicious emails straight to your junk folder so your email service learns to block them.
Let unknown calls go to voicemail. Scammers use virtual phone numbers to call from a new number every day, so blocking one number at a time rarely stops them. If a caller is real, they will leave a message, and you can look up the organization’s real phone number yourself before calling back3.
Secure anything you shared in the first scam. If you sent a copy of your driver’s license, passport, or Social Security number, follow our guide to get a police report for identity theft and freeze your credit. If you let a caller onto your computer, remove the remote access software right away.
Report the contact. If you paid a scammer, call your bank first to see if they can stop the payment, then see our full guide on what to do after a scam. Report recovery scam calls to the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov4.
Common questions
Can I pay a service to remove my name from a victim list?
No. These lists are private files traded by criminals, so no real company has access to delete them. Anyone who offers to remove your name from a scammer list for a fee is running another scam.
How did a caller know the exact amount I lost?
The first scammer wrote down how much you paid and sold that note along with your name and phone number. Knowing the exact dollar amount is a trick to make you believe the new caller is from the government or your bank.
Should I change my phone number?
Most people do not need to change their number. Silencing unknown callers on your phone stops the ringing while letting people in your contacts list come through as normal. If the calls still feel overwhelming after a few weeks, you can ask your phone company for a new number.
For more information
- Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) | Fictitious Law Firms Targeting Cryptocurrency Scam Victims Combine Multiple Exploitation Tactics While Offering to Recover Fundsic3.gov
- Refund and Recovery Scams - FTC Consumer Adviceconsumer.ftc.gov
- Have you lost money to a scam? Watch for scammers who say ...consumer.ftc.gov
- Worried about crypto exchange losses? Don’t pay money for “help” recovering money | Consumer Adviceconsumer.ftc.gov