Skip to content

How a Former Bank Employee Lost $9,600 to a Call From Her ‘Bank’

Jessica Metcalf used to work for Santander Bank. When a caller knew her recent purchases and asked for help catching a dishonest teller, she lost $9,600.

Real StoriesNovember 10, 20265 min read

Jessica Metcalf of Oxford, Massachusetts, is a Santander Bank customer who used to work for the bank1. Because of her past job, she told Boston 25 News, she knew how fraudsters work and knew the bank had systems to watch for fraud.

When her phone rang after a text alert about her credit card, what the caller knew about her accounts convinced her the bank’s fraud team was really on the line.

What happened

According to Boston 25 News, it began when Metcalf got a text message warning her about a suspicious purchase on her credit card. She ignored the text. Then her phone rang.

The caller said they worked with Santander Bank’s fraud protection team and were calling about recent activity on her account. The caller knew the last four digits of her account number and her debit card number. They also named real purchases she had recently made.

Next, the caller asked her to read back a one‑time security code sent to her phone by text. A one-time security code is a short number a bank sends to verify it is really you signing in. The text message warned that Santander would never call and ask for that code, Boston 25 News reported, but the caller’s knowledge of her account convinced Metcalf to read it aloud. She told the station that giving the code let the scammers into her accounts.

The caller then told Metcalf it looked like a bank teller at a branch in nearby Webster was trying to wire money out of her account. Wiring money means sending it electronically from one bank to another. The caller said she could help catch the employee stealing by going to that branch.

According to Metcalf, the caller said the bank would put a $9,600 “provisional credit”—a temporary credit—into her account. She was told to go inside, withdraw that cash so the bank could catch the teller, and hand the money to an agent waiting in the parking lot.

Metcalf drove to the Webster branch, took out the cash, and handed it to a person in the parking lot whom she believed was a bank official.

When she got home, she found that money was missing from other accounts linked to the one she had used. According to a police report reviewed by Boston 25 News, the $9,600 had not come from the bank. Metcalf told the station the scammers had moved money into her main account from three linked accounts she shared with family members, making it look like the bank had added a temporary credit.

How the fake teller-investigation scam worked
  1. A text alert followed by a call

    Metcalf got a text about a suspicious card purchase, followed by a call from someone claiming to be Santander fraud protection who knew her card digits and real recent purchases.

  2. Asking for the one-time security code

    The caller asked her to read back a security code sent to her phone, which she said gave the scammers access to her bank accounts.

  3. Faking a temporary credit

    Using access to her accounts, the scammers moved $9,600 from three of her linked family accounts into her main account and told her it was a temporary credit from the bank.

  4. The cash handoff

    The caller told her to withdraw the $9,600 at a nearby branch to help catch a dishonest teller, then hand the cash to someone posing as a bank official in the parking lot.

What happened afterward

Metcalf asked Santander to refund the money, arguing that she had not approved the electronic transfers between her accounts. She told Boston 25 News that a bank employee told her the transfer requests came from an IP address—a number that identifies a computer connection—in Brookline.

Santander denied her claim. In a letter Metcalf shared with Boston 25 News, the bank wrote that the claim was denied because she confirmed she had completed the withdrawal. A bank spokesperson told the station it could not comment on her case due to customer privacy, that it was working with law enforcement, and that Santander never asks for passwords or remote access to accounts. Metcalf told the station she was considering legal action.

Webster police opened an investigation with an officer who also serves on an FBI task force in Worcester. Metcalf told police the person who took the cash drove off in a blue Chevy Traverse, and she gave officers part of the license plate number. Webster Police Chief Michael Shaw told Boston 25 News that investigators got video from the branch parking lot, and that getting money back in cases like this is very hard.

Why it worked

Metcalf knew from working at Santander that the bank monitors accounts for fraud. When a caller followed up on a text alert and recited the last four digits of her account and card numbers along with real purchases, it matched what she expected a real fraud call to sound like.

Once the scammers had the one‑time security code, they were able to move her own family’s money between her accounts. That made the $9,600 balance increase look like a real credit from the bank. Telling her that a teller inside the branch was the thief gave a believable reason to withdraw cash and hand it to someone outside rather than talking to staff at the counter.

Metcalf told Boston 25 News she was so worried about her accounts being safe that she missed warning signs during the call, and that the experience left her feeling “attacked” and “embarrassed and stupid”.

What you can do

If you get a call or text about fraud on your account, hang up right away, as Webster Police Chief Michael Shaw advised in the Boston 25 News report. Callers can "spoof" a phone number, which means making a fake name or number show up on your screen.

  1. Look up your bank’s phone number on the back of your debit or credit card, or on your paper statement, and call that number yourself.

  2. Never read a one-time security code to anyone on the phone, even if they know your recent purchases or card digits.

  3. If a caller asks you to take out cash, move money, or keep a secret from the teller at your branch, end the call and speak to a branch manager inside.

If you have already shared a code or handed over money, call your bank right away using the number on the back of your card to freeze your accounts, and file a report with your local police department. It is not your fault.

For more information

  1. Spoof & Steal: Scam victim fights to get money back in elaborate imposter schemeboston25news.com

Keep reading

Fake Phone Calls That Look Like Your Bank

Caller ID can show your bank’s real name and number on a scam call. Learn how to spot a fake bank call and what to do if you shared a code.

How the scam worksPhone Call Scams