Skip to content

What to Do if a Buyer Says They Overpaid You

Did a buyer on Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, or eBay say they accidentally overpaid you? Do not send money back yet. Here is how to check safely.

Money and creditNovember 10, 20263 min read

Do not send any money back yet. When someone buying an item from you on Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, or eBay says they paid too much by mistake and asks for the extra back, it is almost always a scam.

The buyer wants you to send your own money before you realize their payment was fake or came from a stolen account. Take a moment to check your own account directly before you reply or hand over the item.

What it looks like

After you agree on a price, the buyer sends a message in your chat app. They say they typed the wrong amount and need the extra money back right away.

Unknown sender

Message request
Today 9:41 AM

Hey, I'm so sorry, I accidentally sent you $250 instead of $150! I got an error message from Apple, but my bank said it went through.

Red flags in this message

  • The buyer says they paid too much and asks you to send the difference back.

  • The buyer says the payment showed an error, but their bank says it went through. Check your own app, not their word.

  • The payment may never have settled, or may be reversed later, so money you already sent back may be gone.

Sometimes the buyer mails a paper check for more than the sale price and asks you to wire back the difference1. Other times, they send a screenshot — a picture of their phone screen — that looks like a payment receipt.

How the overpayment trick works
  1. The buyer claims a mistake

    They send a fake receipt, a bad check, or a payment from a stolen card for more than your asking price.

  2. They rush you for a refund

    They give an urgent reason, such as paying rent or a mover, so you send the difference right away.

  3. You send your own money

    You transfer the extra amount to them, or to a third person they name.

  4. The original payment disappears

    Your bank or payment app discovers the payment from the buyer was fake or stolen and takes the whole amount back from your account.

Red flags

Watch for these warning signs when selling an item online:

  • The buyer says they accidentally sent too much. Payment apps make the sender confirm the dollar amount before any money goes out2. Typing an extra hundred dollars by accident is rare.

  • They point to their bank’s word, a screenshot, or an email as proof. Scammers fake receipts and emails to make you think you were paid.

  • They ask you to refund them through a different app or to another person. For example, they claim they paid with Apple Pay, then ask you to send the refund to a Venmo account or to a shipping agent.

  • They send a check for more than the asking price. Even if a deposited check shows in your balance, it can take weeks for your bank to find out the check is fake.

What to do

Follow these steps in order to protect your item and your money and credit.

  1. Send nothing back. Do not transfer money, mail cash, or buy gift cards to cover the difference. If a buyer sends a check for more than the price, do not cash or deposit it. Keep your item with you.

  2. Open your bank or payment app yourself. Do not tap any links in the buyer’s messages or emails. Open your own app or type your bank’s address into your browser and check your balance and payment history.

  3. If no payment is there, stop talking to the buyer. Walk away from the sale. You can report the buyer’s profile on the marketplace site and block them.

  4. If a payment is there, do not refund it yourself. Even when money shows up, the buyer may have used a stolen card. The steps are the same as when someone sends money by mistake on Zelle or Venmo: contact your bank or the payment app through its official customer service number, explain what happened, and let them handle it. You can tell the buyer to ask their own bank or payment app to cancel the payment.

For more information

  1. Fake check scam targets online car sellers | Consumer Adviceconsumer.ftc.gov
  2. 5 Warning Signs of a Payment App Scamdeltacommunitycu.com

Keep reading

More in Money and credit