Skip to content

How a California Mother Lost $5,400 to a Fake Kidnapping Call

A Navy veteran in California heard what sounded like her daughter crying on the phone and paid $5,400 before learning her daughter was safe at work.

Real StoriesUpdated November 10, 20266 min read

Deborah Del Mastro is a Navy veteran and mother in California1. She told Fox News that she is the kind of person who stays calm during an emergency and runs toward a crisis. She and her husband live on Social Security and income from other work.

One morning while the couple was eating breakfast, a phone call from a local area code drew them into a five‑and-a‑half-hour ordeal that cost them $5,400.

What happened

According to Fox News, Deborah answered a call showing her local area code. A man on the line asked who she was, and then asked if her 37-year‑old daughter, Sarah, was prone to panic attacks.

Deborah heard noise in the background, and then another voice came on the phone crying and struggling to breathe. Deborah told Fox News that the voice said, “I’m so sorry, Mom. I’m so scared,” and that it sounded just like Sarah. Sarah had gone through a breakup days earlier, and Deborah had recently heard her daughter crying in that same way.

The man claimed he had ties to a Mexican drug cartel. He said Sarah had her phone out in a parking lot when she saw something she should not have seen, and that his boss ordered him to take her. He demanded $20,000, saying they would sell Sarah if Deborah did not pay.

According to Fox News, the caller told Deborah to charge her phone or bring a charger, and warned that if her phone died before they were finished, she would never see Sarah again.

He ordered Deborah to keep the line open so he could hear everything around her. When she muted the phone once to talk privately with her husband, the caller noticed, screamed at her, and warned her against trying “funny business”.

Deborah told the man they did not have $20,000, explaining that she had about $2,000 in savings. He directed her to a nearby Walmart to wire money to Mexico through MoneyGram. He told her that people were watching her in the parking lot and that undercover police were nearby. He also told her what to say if anyone asked about the transfer: that she was helping a relative with medical bills.

While her husband drove and the caller listened over the open phone line, Deborah went from place to place. Across four transactions using MoneyGram and Western Union, she sent a total of $5,400. That was all the money she and her husband could reach. Deborah told Fox News that nobody at the stores questioned the transfers or asked if she was alright.

Hours into the call, after Deborah kept asking to speak with her daughter, the caller let her say one scripted sentence: “This nightmare is nearly over. We’re going to come get you as soon as we can”. The voice that sounded like Sarah replied, “I’m so sorry, Mom. I love you”. Then a second man got on the phone, made harsher threats, and demanded more money.

After five and a half hours, the caller told Deborah they had let Sarah go outside the Walmart where Deborah and her husband were parked, and hung up. Deborah got out of the car and looked for her daughter by the entrance, but Sarah was not there. Deborah then dialed Sarah’s number directly. Sarah answered from work, completely safe.

What happened afterward

Deborah told Fox News that she had “never been so relieved to be scammed in my life”. After work, Sarah went to her parents’ house, and the family reported the crime to their local police department.

When Deborah described the call, Sarah, who works in information technology (IT), said the voice was probably an artificial intelligence (AI) clone of her voice. AI voice cloning uses computer software to copy how a person sounds. Deborah told Fox News she did not know that kind of technology existed before the call, and she believes an AI copy of her daughter’s voice was used.

The next morning, Deborah shared what happened on Facebook. Friends encouraged her to set up a GoFundMe page limited to replacing the $5,400 the couple had lost, and her community raised the full amount back. Even so, Deborah told a U.S. Senate committee months later that she remained “completely traumatized”. She and Sarah now use a location-sharing app on their phones so they can check where each other is.

Why it worked

The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) calls this crime “virtual kidnapping,” where criminals claim they are holding a loved one who is actually safe. Several pieces of the deception worked together to keep Deborah from discovering the truth sooner:

  • A familiar number and a familiar sound. The call arrived from a local area code. Scammers often use virtual phone numbers or caller ID tricks to make a call look local, a trick called neighbor spoofing. Then, hearing a crying voice that sounded just like her daughter triggered a parent’s deepest fear. According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), scammers can take a short audio clip of a person’s voice from online and use software to make a call sound like them.

  • Keeping the line open. According to the FBI, virtual kidnappers work hard to keep victims on the phone so they cannot call their loved one to check on them. By demanding that Deborah bring a charger and leave the phone unmuted, the caller stopped her from talking privately with her husband or calling Sarah.

  • A scripted cover story. According to the FTC, urgency and secrecy are common signs of family emergency scams. Giving Deborah a story about medical bills prepared her to answer questions if a store clerk noticed the wire transfers.

What you can do

Whether a scam arrives as a terrifying voice call or one of the common fake family emergency texts, you do not need to be able to spot fake audio to protect your family. Instead, you can verify the person’s safety using a separate path.

  1. Call your loved one directly on a number you already know. The FTC recommends calling the family member at the phone number you have saved for them. If the caller is trying to keep your phone tied up, ask your spouse or someone nearby to make the call from a second phone, or hang up and dial your loved one yourself. If they do not answer, call someone who should know where they are, such as their workplace.

  2. Agree on a family safe word and a way to check locations. The FBI recommends picking a private family code word that could not be guessed from social media. Because a caller may not let you speak freely to the person on the line, you can also agree with close family to share phone locations or to always verify an emergency before anyone sends money.

  3. Treat demands for wire transfers and secrecy as warning signs. The FTC warns that scammers often demand wire transfers, gift cards, or cryptocurrency (digital money) because those payments move quickly and are hard to get back.

For more information

  1. AI voice scam traps mom in 5-hour kidnapping nightmarefoxnews.com

Keep reading

Fake Phone Calls That Look Like Your Bank

Caller ID can show your bank’s real name and number on a scam call. Learn how to spot a fake bank call and what to do if you shared a code.

How the scam worksPhone Call Scams