Joseph Tiegue is a Pennsylvania man who had been saving money in a retirement account with Fidelity Investments1. When a text message arrived asking about a large grocery store charge on his card, he answered it.
What happened
Tiegue told NBC10 Philadelphia that the trouble started with a text message on his phone that looked like it came from Fidelity Investments.
Text Message
Today 9:41 AM
Red flags in this message
Tiegue replied to the message. Soon after, his phone rang. He told NBC10 that the caller ID on his screen read “Fidelity Investments.”
The caller began by asking Tiegue to confirm his personal information. Next, a text message with a set of numbers arrived on Tiegue’s phone, and the caller asked him to read those numbers back out loud. Tiegue read the numbers to the caller.
Shortly after that call, someone got into his retirement account and took more than $9,000.
Tiegue filed a claim with Fidelity the same day. Weeks later, the company sent him a letter denying his claim. According to NBC10, the letter stated that because he had interacted with a phishing link and shared his one‑time security password with an unknown party, the company’s protection guarantee would not cover the loss. Phishing is when a scammer sends a fake message that looks like it comes from a company you trust to trick you into giving away private information.
Why it worked
Every part of this scam was set up to look like standard fraud protection. Many banks and investment firms send real text alerts to check on unusual card charges. Answering “no” to a $503.50 charge you did not make is what cardholders are used to doing.
Once a person replies to a fake fraud text, scammers know the phone number is active and that the person is worried about their account. They follow up right away with a phone call that shows the company's real name on caller ID. Faking the name or number that shows up on your phone screen is called spoofing.
The most important step is the text message with the numbers. A one‑time security password, also called a verification code, is a short number a company sends to your phone to prove that it is really you logging in or moving money. When a scammer tries to get into your account, the real company sends that code to your phone. By asking you to read the numbers aloud as part of a security check, the scammer gets the key they need to enter your account.
Because the account holder is the one who read the real security code to the caller, financial companies often treat the login as authorized and refuse to refund the money.
What you can do
If you get a text or a phone call about a suspicious charge, do not reply to the text and do not trust the caller ID. In a statement to NBC10, Fidelity advised that if someone messages you asking for personal information, you should not reply, and if someone calls asking for personal information, you should hang up.
Instead, check on the account yourself. Go to the company’s real website or call the phone number printed on your monthly statement or the back of your card. Knowing what to do when someone asks you to read back a verification code helps you stop the call before any money moves.
If you already answered a call like this or read a code aloud, follow our checklist for what to do if you gave your bank details to a caller right away so you can call your financial company on its real number and lock down your account. It is not your fault.