A man in Boardman, Ohio, was at work on a Tuesday when his phone rang1. According to local television stations WFMJ and WKBN, which both cited a Boardman police report, the caller was a woman who said she worked for Huntington Bank. She told him someone was trying to take money out of his account.
He told her he could not talk because he was at work. Police say the caller told him to go to a Huntington Bank branch the next morning.
What happened
When the man arrived at a branch in Boardman, he called the number back2. According to the police report, the woman put him on a three-way call with a second person who claimed to be a federal agent.
The callers told him the branch was under investigation for what they called “dirty employees”. They instructed him to withdraw $20,000 from his account and said the agent would watch him on a video feed from inside the bank. He withdrew the cash while staying on the phone with the caller.
Next, the callers told him to go to another branch and withdraw $15,000 the same way. He followed their instructions while still on the phone.
Police say the man got a box for the $35,000 in cash and asked to speak with the sheriff. Soon after, he received a call that looked like it came from the Mahoning County Sheriff’s Office. The caller used spoofing, which is a tool that makes a false name and phone number appear on caller ID. The person on the line claimed to be the sheriff and told him to hand the box of money to two men waiting at the Boardman Plaza.
According to WKBN, the man met the two men at the plaza and gave them the box. He later told police that one of the men drove a Tesla and the other drove a Chevy Spark.
The man stayed on the phone with the caller even as he returned home. The caller then told him to withdraw more money, so he drove to another bank branch.
At that branch, the teller thought the withdrawal seemed suspicious and asked to speak to the person on the phone. As soon as the teller started talking, the caller hung up.
The teller told the man it was a scam and advised him to file a police report. As of October 9, 2026, WFMJ reported that no arrests had been made and no charges had been filed.
A call about account fraud
A caller claiming to be from Huntington Bank warned the man that someone was trying to take money from his account.
A story about dishonest staff
On a three-way call with a fake federal agent, the callers claimed the local branch was being investigated for dishonest employees.
Watched withdrawals
The callers told him to take out $20,000 at one branch and $15,000 at another while they claimed to watch the bank video feed.
A spoofed call from the sheriff
When he asked to speak to the sheriff, a caller using the number of the Mahoning County sheriff told him to hand the boxed cash to two men at a local plaza.
Why it worked
The callers built a story that explained away every reason to stop and ask questions. First, they did not demand money while he was busy at work, which made the initial call seem routine. Telling him to visit a real bank branch the next morning sounded like safe, standard advice.
Once he arrived at the bank, claiming the branch staff were under investigation gave the man a reason not to trust the people standing in front of him. In scams like this, claiming that tellers are dishonest keeps the customer from talking openly with the very people trained to spot fraud. Claiming to watch the bank’s security cameras made the caller seem like a real investigator with inside access.
Finally, when the man asked to speak with the sheriff, the scammers had an answer ready. Because caller ID can be faked to show a real phone number, the call appearing to come from the Mahoning County Sheriff’s Office looked like proof that local law enforcement was leading the operation.
What you can do
If someone calls to say your bank account is in danger, or that you need to move money to help with an investigation, take these steps:
Hang up the phone. If a caller tells you to stay on the line while you drive to the bank or speak to a teller, end the call.
Look up the bank’s official phone number on the back of your debit card or on your paper statement. Never call back a number that a caller gave you, even if they told you to wait until the next day.
Talk openly with the bank teller or branch manager. If a caller says the local staff are under investigation and cannot be trusted, tell the branch manager right away.
If you already shared account information or followed instructions from a suspicious caller, call your bank right away using the number on your card and follow our checklist on what to do if you gave your bank details to a caller. It is not your fault, and acting quickly can help protect your remaining accounts.