Swetali Khapekar is a tech worker in Silicon Valley who lived in Milpitas, California1. In April 2016, KGO‑TV (ABC7 San Francisco) reported that she and her sister lost all of their savings to callers posing as tax agents and police.
What happened
Khapekar was at work when her phone rang. She told KGO‑TV that the caller said she had an unpaid federal tax difference and a legal case against her. The man on the line said she owed about $17,000.
She did not believe him at first. She looked up the 800 number on her caller ID using Google. The search showed that the number belonged to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).
The caller told her to pay right away or she would be arrested immediately. Khapekar still had doubts. She told the caller she needed to speak with the police.
Within minutes, her phone rang again with a local 408 area code. She searched Google for that number too, and it matched the Santa Clara Police Department. Khapekar recalled what the second caller told her on the phone:
What the caller says
This is pretty serious. We have been asked by the IRS to have arrest warrants against you.
Incoming call
Santa Clara Police Department
mobile
Red flags on this call
After that call, Khapekar agreed to cooperate. A caller stayed on the phone with her as she drove to her bank and then to a Walmart, where she sent $1,800 by wire transfer. A wire transfer is an electronic way to send money quickly from one person to another.
The caller told her that her file was still under review and that more penalties were showing up. He told her to wire another $1,900.
The demands went on the next day. Over two days, Khapekar wired money eight times, sending a total of $16,000. The payments emptied both her bank account and her sister’s account. She told KGO‑TV that she was so stressed during those two days that she could not think straight.
When the callers kept demanding money, Khapekar decided she could not take it anymore. She drove to the Santa Clara Police Department to turn herself in, ready to go to jail.
At the station, officers told her it was an IRS scam. Neither the police nor the IRS had called her. Khapekar told KGO‑TV that the money was gone with no trace, leaving her and her sister without money for rent or food. Friends set up an online fundraiser to help them recover, and Khapekar spoke with the news station.
Why it worked
Khapekar checked the phone number when she got a suspicious call. The scammers anticipated this. According to KGO‑TV, they used a device and internet phone tools to fake the caller ID, making real IRS and Santa Clara Police Department numbers show up on her screen.
When Khapekar pushed back and asked to talk to the police, the scammers used that request to build a trap. By calling her right back from a number that matched the local police station, they seemed to confirm the first caller’s story.
The callers also kept her on the phone while she drove to the bank and the store, and they kept the pressure on for two days. Staying on the line and threatening arrest gives a person no quiet moment to step back or talk things over with someone else.
What you can do
Know how the IRS contacts you. In a 2017 follow-up report by KGO‑TV, the IRS explained that even when private debt collectors work on its behalf, the agency always sends two written notices by postal mail before any phone call happens2. The IRS also stated that a real collector will never demand payment by wire transfer or debit card, and will never threaten to arrest you in fake IRS phone calls.
Do not trust caller ID on an incoming call. Because callers can fake the number that appears on your screen, searching the number on Google will show the real agency even when the caller is a scammer.
Hang up and call the agency yourself. If you are worried a call might be real, end the call. Wait a few minutes, look up the official number for the agency or your local police department yourself, and dial it directly.
If you have already sent money to someone claiming to be from the IRS or the police, contact your bank or the wire transfer company right away to ask if the transfer can be stopped. It is not your fault. Then report what happened to your local police department.